MIT Lawyers Get Subpoena Over Tupac     

File Photo
Posted by Robert
Rap News Network
1/17/2004 8:19:46 PM
Home > News
MIT Lawyers Get Subpoena Over Tupac
Related CDs & DVDs

Best Of 2Pac-Part 1:Thug (2007)
List Price: $11.98
Our Price: $9.97
You Save: $2.01
News: MIT Counsel Responds To Tupac Allegations

Tupac may be dead, but his lawyers are not. On Dec. 10, MIT received a subpoena from Paramount Pictures asking who is responsible for an MIT computer that allegedly distributed illegal copies of the film “Tupac: Resurrection.”

The Internet address provided by Paramount belongs to a computer at the headquarters of the Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering. The studio said it was able to download an unauthorized copy of the film at 1:40 a.m. on Dec. 4, and has asked MIT to identify the person responsible.

MIT’s deadline to respond is tomorrow, Jan. 15. The senior counsel for intellectual property, Ann M. Hammersla, said the Institute’s lawyers are still planning a response. “We’re working on it. It’s still under discussion,” she said. “We are considering all possibilities.”

MIT person unlikely to be at fault

The subpoena says that Paramount was able to download the film over Internet Relay Chat from the Internet Protocol address, a computer in 2-190, the Course I headquarters.

Patricia A. Dixon, a Course I administrative officer listed as the computer’s contact, declined to discuss the matter.

Based on the IRC “nickname” of the alleged trader (“BJ-XDCC1063”) and the time of day, it appears unlikely that a real person was present at the department headquarters to send the film to Paramount.

A more likely scenario is that the computer was remotely compromised by someone who then used it as a middleman to share the content via IRC. “That’s being considered,” said Timothy J. McGovern, the StopIt and Information Technology policy coordinator.

Paramount’s lawyer handling the subpoena did not respond to repeated requests for comment.

Verizon ruling no help to MIT

How MIT plans to respond is still a mystery, even though the deadline is tomorrow. (MIT obtained an extension from the original deadline of Dec. 17.)

One thing that is almost certain is that the Dec. 19 decision of a federal appeals court, striking down some subpoenas, will not help MIT in this case.

The Digital Millenium Copyright Act of 1998 grants copyright owners the power, in some situations, to subpoena Internet service providers for the identity of users trading copyrighted works without authorization.

The Washington, D.C., federal appeals court’s decision held that a DMCA subpoena cannot force Internet service providers to disclose the contact information of their subscribers if the alleged infringing material is hosted on computers not belonging to the ISP.

The decision, had it been made earlier in 2003, would have given MIT the right not to release the contact information of Claudiu A. Prisnel ’06, whose name MIT disclosed to the Recording Industry Association of America as the “alleged infringer” who offered hundreds of songs over the KaZaA file-trading network through MIT’s network. (Prisnel was not sued and was not contacted by the RIAA, he said.)

But the court’s decision seems not to aid MIT in its current situation, since the machine is an MIT-owned computer.

“Our working hypothesis right now is that [the decision] is not relevant, because the machine is owned by MIT,” McGovern said. “That’s the current interpretation. A lot of this stuff is still under discussion,” he said

2Pac Biography, 2Pac News, 2Pac Audio Streams, 2Pac Music Videos, 2Pac Pictures, 2Pac Interviews, 2Pac CD & DVD Releases, 2Pac Chat, 2Pac Song Lyrics, 2Pac Web Links
Official Site
Options Email 
2Pac's Mother Responds To LA Times Article
"Rollin' With Dre" Tells About 2 Decades With Dr. Dre
Shakur Estate Files Injunction Against Death Row Records
Tupac Shakur Estate Partners With EverGreen Copyrights
Tupac Amaru Shakur Foundation Add Presenters To Awards
Tupac Amaru Shakur Foundation Seeks Filmmaker Entries
First Semi-Annual Tupac Amaru Shakur Film Screening Announced
BET Offers Black History Month TV Specials
Brand New 2Pac (Tupac Shakur) Hip-Hop CD Released
Many Hip Hop Events To Celebrate 2Pac's New Album
Tupac (2Pac) Shakur Gets Revived On "Pac's Life" Album
Hip Hop DVD Profiles "Death Before Dishonor"
Various photos used on this site have been used with permission from the copyright holder Gobi. Find more in his book "Thru My Eyes."
Copyright 1998-2008 Tupac-Online. All rights reserved. Rap News Network